Many people throughout the Wichita Falls community began sharing concerns after looking at the most recent city council meeting agenda. While most everything looked in order, something was missing. The portion of the meeting retained for public comment, Citizen Comments, didn’t appear on the November 17 agenda.

For years, citizen comments have acted as a way for citizens to address the council and share praises or concerns in a public setting. Usually, there is a designated amount of time for each speaker with an overall time limit for public comment, and the council is generally not allowed to start a discussion with the speaker. 

It’s also important to note that citizens are still able to speak on agenda items throughout the meeting. Dark Roast Report received feedback from many in the community with a majority considering this an effort to silence voices. However, Mayor Tim Short said he doesn’t believe that’s the case and people can still speak on agenda items.

While many municipalities have a form of audience participation, based on state law, it’s actually not required with some cities across Texas doing away with it. 

According to Short, unofficial discussions to remove the public comments started during summertime. Short said that there were a multitude of reasons this decision was made, but that there are “so many better and more efficient ways to address concerns”.

“No one should have to wait two weeks to have a one way conversation,” Short explained in a statement.

Journalism like this is only made possible through community support. If you believe in Dark Roast Report’s mission, consider becoming a member.

Get Involved

However, Dark Roast Report spoke with two citizens: Crystal Washington and Amy Jones-Walker, who disagreed with Short’s perspective on the matter.

Washington, who often takes the time to attend city council meetings and request to speak, said she’s fully aware that the public comment portion wasn’t meant for a two-way discussion. She said she would go speak to bring awareness to things going on, such as the arrest of Victoria Lang.

“These people are playing with their authority,” Washington stated. 

Jones-Walker went to the November 17 council meeting in hopes to address the council with what she said was a previous deal made between the Chamber and her business, Withershins Menagerie, by the former Chamber Director Ron Kitchens. However, she understood it wasn’t going to be a discussion.

“I wasn’t expecting a discussion of my presentation,” Jones-Walker stated. “I was hoping they would listen and then get back to me with help.”

Both citizens agreed that the decision to remove public comments didn’t benefit the community in any way as the option to reach out directly to the council has always been available. It was the nature of being able to speak publicly that they found important. 

“People should be allowed to talk to the council and our public as a whole,” Jones-Walker expressed.

“It’s bringing something to the forefront so your peers can hear, other departments can hear. That’s what it’s for,” Washington said. 

Washington went on to say that it’s a filtering system that leaves concerns left out of public view. Mayor Short, on the other hand, stated that you can call your council representative and have your concern placed on the agenda, or you can visit with them before or after the meeting.

“There is no advantage to having a one way conversation at a meeting towards resolving an issue,” Short said. 

However, both Washington and Jones-Walker said that they often have issues getting in contact with their representatives. Jones-Walker said she had been sending messages for a while that have gone unread. Washington added to that point, saying she didn’t have a problem getting in contact with her representative, Councilman Robert Brooks, but that she has trouble getting in contact with anyone else on the council, which is why she says people end up participating in the public comments.

When asked if there was going to be anything new implemented to replace that method of communication, Mayor Short brought up the town halls and public hearings that have been held in the past, stating there have been over 30 in the last three years, which averages less than one a month (using 30 as the example) throughout the entire city. Short explained that they’re typically in the evenings and very well advertised.

Short also added that he doesn’t see citizens' comments returning to the agenda. He also said that it wasn’t necessary to make the decision in council as it was simply procedural.

“What we’re doing with our agenda and meetings now is much more efficient for our citizens,” Short said. 

From every resident Dark Roast Report spoke with, they all agreed that they believe the action to remove what they viewed as a very important piece of the city council meeting should have been discussed and voted on in council.

“It’s a viewpoint discrimination,” Washington said.

“The more the public is involved, the more successful our town will be,” Jones-Walker said.